| Year |
Horse |
Reason unsuccessful |
| 1877 |
Cloverbrook |
Did not start in Derby |
| 1878 |
Duke of Magenta |
Did not start in Derby |
| 1880 |
Grenada |
Did not start in Derby |
| 1881 |
Saunterer |
Did not start in Derby |
| 1895 |
Belmar |
Did not start in Derby |
| 1920 |
Man o’ War |
Did not start in Derby |
| 1922 |
Pillory |
Did not start in Derby |
| 1923 |
Zev |
12th to Virgil, Preakness |
| 1931 |
Twenty Grand |
2nd to Mate, Preakness |
| 1939 |
Johnstown |
5th to Challedon, Preakness |
| 1940 |
Bimelech |
2nd to Gallahadion, Derby |
| 1942 |
Shut Out |
5th to Alsab, Preakness |
| 1949 |
Capot |
2nd to Ponder, Derby |
| 1950 |
Middleground |
2nd to Hill Prince, Preakness |
| 1953 |
Native Dancer |
2nd to Dark Star, Derby |
| 1955 |
Nashua |
2nd to Swaps, Derby |
| 1956 |
Needles |
2nd to Fabius, Preakness |
| 1963 |
Chateaugay |
2nd to Candy Spots, Preakness |
| 1967 |
Damascus |
3rd to Proud Clarion, Derby |
| 1972 |
Riva Ridge |
4th to Bee Bee Bee, Preakness |
| 1974 |
Little Current |
2nd to Cannonade, Derby |
| 1976 |
Bold Forbes |
3rd to Elocutionist, Preakness |
| 1984 |
Swale |
7th to Gate Dancer, Preakness |
| 1988 |
Risen Star |
3rd to Winning Colors, Derby |
| 1991 |
Hansel |
10th to Strike the Gold, Derby |
| 1994 |
Tabasco Cat |
6th to Go for Gin, Derby |
| 1995 |
Thunder Gulch |
3rd to Timber Country, Preakness |
| 2001 |
Point Given |
5th to Monarchos, Derby |
| 2005 |
Afleet Alex |
3rd to Giacomo, Derby |
