When you’re tracking the Road to the Kentucky Derby, every week matters — and this past weekend delivered big-time shakeups in the NTRA Top Three-Year-Old Poll. With Commandment proving himself around two turns in the Fountain of Youth (G2) and Class President edging Silent Tactic in the Rebel (G2), the 3-year-old class is quickly taking shape.
As one of this week’s official NTRA poll voters alongside Aaron Halterman, I — Jared Welch — have locked in my rankings and compared them with Halterman’s to give you the consensus Top 10 Kentucky Derby contenders and what it really means moving forward.
🥇 1. Commandment
No debate here.
Both Halterman and I ranked Commandment No. 1 after his two-turn breakthrough in the Fountain of Youth (G2). The Brad Cox trainee answered the stamina question emphatically and now sits firmly as a legit Derby threat.
He has tactical speed, class, and professionalism — three traits that travel well to Churchill Downs. If he continues progressing, he’ll be one of the likely Derby favorites.
Consensus Rank: 1
🥈 2. Chief Wallabee
Both Dudes also agreed on the No. 2 spot.
Chief Wallabee may not have won the Fountain of Youth, but his effort stamped him as a serious Derby contender. He ran a monster race, showed grit, and continues to trend forward.
He might not have beaten Commandment Saturday — but not sure the same result would happen again.
Consensus Rank: 2
🥉 3. Class President
The Rebel Stakes (G2) winner surged up the rankings after his thrilling nose victory at Oaklawn.
I ranked him No. 3, while Halterman slotted him at No. 5, giving him a strong consensus position near the top.
He proved he can battle, handle two turns, and defeat high-quality competition. And yes — we nailed him at 8-1 👀.
Consensus Rank: 3
4. Paladin
I think we both respect Paladin’s upside, though there’s slight disagreement on exact placement.
- Halterman: No. 3
- Welch: No. 5
Paladin continues to show professionalism and forward progression. He hasn’t delivered the signature knockout punch yet — but the foundation is there. I could still totally see him being a Derby favorite.
Consensus Rank: 4
5. Silent Tactic
I ranked Silent Tactic as high as No. 4, while Halterman placed him at No. 7.
After battling in the Rebel and previously winning the Southwest, Silent Tactic has proven he belongs in the top tier. His consistency makes him dangerous every time he enters the gate, although I do somewhat question his ability to win the Derby barring a pace meltdown.
Consensus Rank: 5
6. Nearly
A steady climber.
Both Halterman (No. 4) and I (No. 6) continue to show confidence in Nearly. He hasn’t delivered a flashy win recently, but the talent remains obvious.
The next prep will tell us whether he’s a serious Derby win candidate or more of a superfecta horse.
Consensus Rank: 6
7. Renegade
Renegade remains firmly in the second tier — respected, but still needing that breakout moment.
- Halterman: No. 6
- Welch: No. 7
He’s consistent and competitive, but needs a defining performance to jump into the top five.
Consensus Rank: 7
8. Further Ado
Both of us slotted Further Ado at No. 8 — total agreement.
That tells you exactly where he stands: firmly in the mix, but not quite knocking on the door of the top group.
Consensus Rank: 8
9. Chip Honcho
Another horse both voters included in their Top 10.
- Halterman: No. 10
- Welch: No. 10
He may not generate buzz nationally yet, but he’s done enough to earn respect on the Derby trail.
Consensus Rank: 9
10. Golden Tempo / Brant (Split Vote)
Here’s where the ballots differ.
- Halterman included Golden Tempo (No. 9)
- Welch included Brant (No. 9)
Both are fringe Top 10 types with upside, and the next prep likely determines who sticks in the rankings.
Consensus Rank: 10 (Split)
What It All Means
The top of the division is becoming clearer:
- Commandment has separated himself.
- Chief Wallabee is right there.
- The Rebel Stakes reshuffled the deck behind them.
- There is depth — but no invincible superstar (yet).
The beauty of the 2026 Derby trail? It still feels wide open.
And as always, Halterman and I will continue voting weekly in the NTRA Poll while breaking down every prep race on Blinkers Off and across RacingDudes.com.
The Road to Churchill is far from over.
Cash Big At The Kentucky Derby With Us
There’s a reason we’re the #1 trusted source for premium racing picks & info.
